Our Review of the Top Buy Toys By Age Stores Online

Are you looking to do a little online shopping for the little ones this holiday season? Or are you planning on getting a gift for a baby’s birthday? Unfortunately, you'll find that shopping for a baby, or any child, really, is a lot harder than it looks. Not only do you have to know what's appropriate for their age, but it also helps to keep up with current trends; otherwise, you may end up with one of those awkward smiles and no invite to their next birthday party.

In all seriousness, the best way to avoid issues is to shop online with one of the best buy toys by age stores. These are stores that make it easy to buy a toy based on the age of a child. For example, sites like the American Toy Store have categories for babies, teenagers, and everything in between.

To ensure that you don't run into any trouble out there, we cover some of the best stores and compare each one. Learn more in our comprehensive review.

How We Chose the Top Buy Toys By Age Stores

There are hundreds of places to buy toys online. So, you’re probably curious about how we came to the three stores that we cover in this guide. Thankfully, the process was simple, and you can use some of the factors we considered to help with your decision. In fact, you'll find that some stores are stronger in some of these categories than others, so keep that in mind. Learn more about how we chose the best toys by age stores in the sections below.

Toy Selection

First and foremost, we have to start with toy selection. When evaluating the best buy toys by age stores, toy selection is everything. While the stores that we selected all have a great toy selection, you'll find that some options are better than others based on your needs. For example, if you want a puzzle toy for a toddler, MindWare may have more options available than Fat Brain Toys.

However, if you’re looking for quantity and affordability, the American Toy Store is tough to beat. Make sure you consider these factors before you start shopping.

Unique Features

You also need to focus on the unique features that these stores offer. Let's say that you have a child’s birthday party tomorrow and you need gift wrap, a card, and a gift in less than 24 hours. In these cases, you need to choose a store like the American Toy Store that offers gift wrap, cards, and same-day shipping.

On the other hand, if you want to make a gift feel more personal and put a child’s name on it, Fat Brain Toys is a good choice. Every store has unique features, so evaluate them before committing.

Customer Support

Last but not least, you can't leave out customer support. The best companies tend to offer money-back guarantees and simple contact methods. When shopping online, it also helps to consider companies that make it easy to connect with someone. Whether that's via email, phone, or chatbot, you should have options for quick contact.

That said, some companies go beyond the customer. For example, companies like the American Toy Store have great customer support, but they don't support as many causes as a company like Fat Brain Toys, so you may want to choose the latter if the selection is similar in price.

The Top 3 Buy Toys By Age Stores

When you want to buy toys for a child that's a specific age, good luck on some of the bigger platforms like Walmart or Amazon. You’re going to have to comb through a lot of items before you find anything close. For these reasons, we prefer some of the smaller names in the game, as evidenced by our glowing American Toy Store review.

Learn more about this store and the rest of our picks for the best buy toys by age stores below.

1. American Toy Store

Editor's Rating: 5/5
Why We Like the American Toy Store: We love American Toy Store because of how easy the site makes it to find toys for all ages, genders, and development stages.

Quick Facts

• Toys are available for children of all ages, and this includes babies and teenagers.
• Plenty of categories to choose from based on the interests of the child.
• Shipping is available across the United States.

When it comes to the best stores that sell toys for every age group, you can do a lot worse than American Toy Store. This online toy retailer is one of the best in the business, and this is for many reasons. First and foremost, we love that the American Toy Store makes finding toys hassle-free. Categories are available for all ages, and you can further explore them based on gender and interests. The editorial team is also great at keeping up with trends and giving collection recommendations.

That said, American Toy Store also has a massive catalog compared to other sites of its size and scope. You'll find plenty of toys, and they're high-quality toys, too. Therefore, you never have to worry about bouncing around to different sites. American Toy Store also offers gift wrap and cards, which creates a one-stop experience for shopping.

Pros

• 30-day money-back guarantee.
• Same-day shipping is available.
• Gift wrapping and cards are available for special events.
• Excellent category selection, and searching is simple.

Cons

• Not always the easiest company to get in contact with via phone or chat.

2. Fat Brain Toys

Editor's Rating: 4.5/5
Why We Like Fat Brain Toys: Fat Brain Toys is one of our top picks due to the number of ages to choose from, and they even include adults and seniors.

Quick Facts

• Simple search function that streamlines the search process.
• Chatbot function for further assistance.
• A unique toy-naming system that allows you to shop for personalized gifts.

When it comes to a wide selection, you can't go wrong with Fat Brain Toys. This company is a reputable name in the industry, and you'll find that toys are available for every age range. In fact, this goes beyond children. You'll find toys for adults and seniors, and some of the puzzles and adventures are a lot of fun. Fat Brain Toys also makes it easy to find what you’re looking for with an abundance of categories based on interests, age, and gender.

Fat Brain Toys is also very transparent and supports a handful of great causes, like the Team Jack Foundation, which focuses on supporting research for pediatric brain cancer. Aside from this, customer support is fast, responsive, and caring when it comes to your order.

Pros

• The Name Store allows you to choose toys that are customized based on the name of the child.
• The company supports great causes.
• Categories for children and adults of all ages.

Cons

• Shipping may take longer than sites that offer same-day shipping.

3. MindWare

Editor's Rating: 4/5
Why We Like MindWare: We covered a lot of fun toy stores, but MindWare loves to help children learn and develop through fun toys, and that's something we can get behind.

Quick Facts

• Plenty of toys are available for children of all ages and even for adults.
• Plenty of categories for educators, STEM, and much more.
• Gift cards are available for the platform.

MindWare is another one of our favorites, but for a different reason. We know that toys are supposed to be fun, but what if a child could learn from them? During a child’s early years, solving puzzles and playing with toys that encourage learning can have a positive impact on their minds. This is where MindWare thrives because the platform has an abundance of education-focused toys that are perfect for each age group. Searching for them is easy, of course, thanks to the platform’s hassle-free system that lets you search by age.

MindWare also has a wide selection of regular toys, so it's not just toys for learning. The company is also based in the United States and has been since 1990. Furthermore, MindWare offers great deals on shipping, makes it easy to call them, and even enables account creation for a smooth checkout experience.

Pros

• Has a wide variety of toys that focus on mental development.
• 100% Happiness Guarantee, which allows you to exchange any gifts that don't make the cut.
• Free shipping on orders that cost more than $49.

Cons

• Educational focus isn't for everyone, and the selection is limited on the fun side of things.

The Verdict on the Top Buy Toys By Age Stores

At the end of the day, there are dozens of toy stores online, but the three that we covered in this guide are your best choices. That said, our top choice is always the American Toy Store because the process is so easy when you work with them. You never have to worry about coming up empty-handed, and there's a money-back guarantee and same-day shipping, which is great for those last-minute gifts.

Of course, the other stores we covered in this guide are also great alternatives. After all, they're the top three toy stores by age for a reason. Happy shopping!